$B%H%C%W%Z!<%8(B$B!!(B$B%W%m%U%#!<%k(B$B!!(B$B$X$s$F$3F|5-(B$B!!(BMac$B=i?4$N$3$3$m$@$"(B$B!!(B$B%$%i%9%H%l!<%7%g%s(B$B!!(B$B%j%s%/(B$B!!(B$B$*$7$i$;(B





$B!c!&!&!&(B$B2a5n$N5-;v(B$B!&!&!&!d(B

$B!|(B

2005-12

12$B7n(B31$BF|!!!VJI$K8~$+$C$F!W(B

$B:rF|$NCk4V(B
$B?7=I1XA0$N>.ED5^%G%Q!<%H$N(B
$B30JI$K8~$+$C$F(B
$B0l@87|L?6l>p$r8@$C$F$k%*%8%5%s$,$$$?(B
$B%"%O%O(B
$B$"$N!<(B
$BM>7W$J$*@$OC$@$H$O;W$$$^$9$,(B
$B$h$$$*G/$r!*(B

12$B7n(B29$BF|!!!V;E;vG<$a!W(B

$B:#F|$O!V;E;vG<$a!W$N$H$3$bB?$$$i$7$$(B
$B$,(B
$B$=$N;E;v$C$F$I$3$KG<$a$k$s$@$m$&!)(B
$B%"%O%O(B
$BKM$s$H$3$KG<$a$J$$$G$M(B
$B$"!"$$$d(B
$B$3$N$H$3$m2K$@$+$iKM$s$H$3$KG<$a$F$M(B
$B$h$m$7$/!

12$B7n(B28$BF|!!!V??E_!W(B

$BD+$N%i%8%*$NE75$M=Js$N%*%M!<%5%s(B
$B$O(B
$B!V??E_JB$N4($5$G$7$g$&!W(B
$B$C$F(B
$B%*%$%*%$!*(B
2m$B$b@c$,@Q$b$C$F$k$H$3$b$"$k$N$K(B
$B:#$,??E_$H$A$c$&$s$+$$!*(B
$B%"%O%O(B
$BF,Df$l!*(B

12$B7n(B27$BF|!!!VF|IU!W(B

$B:G6a(B
$B$X$s$F$3F|5-$NF|IU$r4V0c$($F$k$3$H$,B?$$(B
$B$5$C$-5$$,$D$$$?$,(B
$B$3$3$O(B
12$B7n(B25$BF|$N$^$^$@$C$?(B
$B$7(B
$B%H%C%W%Z!<%8$O(B12$B7n(B28$BF|(B
$B$C$F(B
$B$^$@Mh$F$J$$F|IU$8$c$s!*(B
$B%*%l$NF,(B
$BE`$C$?$+$"!)(B
$B%"%O%O(B

12$B7n(B26$BF|!!!V2V2PBg2q!)!W(B

$BLk(B8$B;~:"(B
$B%\%3%\%31s$/$G2;$,$9$k(B
$B$N$G(B
$B8<4X$r3+$1$F$_$?(B
$B$i(B
$BKL$NJ}$G2V2PBg2q$d$C$F$k$8$c$s!*(B
$B$"$C(B$B$3$l(B$B$@!*(B
$B$3$N%/%=4($$$N$K(B
$B;`$L$>$*!*(B
$B%"%O%O(B

12$B7n(B25$BF|!!!VK7$5$s%5%s%?!W(B

$B5"$j$NEE $B$,(B
$BESCf$N1X$GL\$r3+$1$?(B
$B$i(B
$BL\$NA0$K(B
$B%H%J%+%$$NK9;R7?$+$V$jJ*(B$B$r$7$?%*%K%$%5%s$,N)$C$F$?(B
$B%"%O%O(B
$B;W$o$:$^$?L\$rJD$8$A$c$C$?$<(B

12$B7n(B24$BF|!!!VK7$5$s%5%s%?!W(B

$B$H$3$m$G(B
$B$*;{$N$*K7$5$s0l2H(B
$B$b(B
$B%/%j%9%^%9$K$O%1!<%-$r?)$Y$k$N$+$J$"!)(B
$B$=$NF|$@$1$O(B
$B%5%s%?$KJQ?H$7$F$?$j$7$F(B
$B%"%O%O%O%O(B

12$B7n(B23$BF|!!!VK~0wEE

$B:rF|$N5"$j(B
$B=*EE6a$$%.%e!<%.%e!<5M$a$NEE $B$G(B
$BKM$N2#$K$$$?%*%8%5%s(B
$B$O(B
$B$J$s$+%V%D%V%D8@$C$F$k$J$"(B
$B$H(B
$B;W$C$F$?(B
$B$i(B
$B%3%i! $B$3$s$J$H$3$G$*7P$NN}=,$9$s$J$"!*(B

12$B7n(B21$BF|!!!V(B-20$B!n0J2

$BE75$M=Js$r8+$F$$$?(B
$B$i(B
$B:#F|$OD9Ln8)$G(B-20$B!n0J2<$N=j$,$"$j(B
$B$C$F(B
$B%R%(! $B$=$l$C$F$P(B
$BKL6K(B$BJB$8$c$s!*(B
$BGr7'$5$s$,0z$C1[$7$F$/$k$>!*(B

12$B7n(B20$BF|!!!V(B2$B%v7nAa$$!W(B

$BCHE_$@$C$?$O$:(B
$B$,(B
2$B%v7n$bAa$/??E_$K$J$C$F(B
$B$D!<$3$H$O(B
2$B7n$K$O29$+$/$J$C$F(B
3$B7n$K$O:y$,:i$/$N$+$"!)(B
$B%"%O%O(B

12$B7n(B19$BF|!!!V@VLL!W(B

$B:#=5(B
$BE7?&$N%(%mK\20!&8w1J$K2q$&(B
$B$,(B
$BJ!2,=P?H$NE[(B
$B$O(B
$BKhF|%I%C%W%j$H%(%m%(%m;E;v$r$7$F$k(B
$B$N$K(B
$B2?8N$@$+(B
$B!V(B$B%\%\%V%i%8%k!*(B$B!W(B
$B$H(B
$B8@$&$H@VLL$9$k(B
$B%"%O%O(B
$B$J$s$G!)(B

12$B7n(B18$BF|!!!VF|K\8l!W(B

$B?7=I$GJb$-%?%P%3$r$7$F$?30?M$5$s(B
$B$O(B
$B4F;k0w$N%*%8%5%s$KCm0U$5$l(B
$B!V%K%[%s%4%o%+%i%J!<%$!*!W(B
$B$r(B
$BO"H/$7$F$$$?(B
$B$,(B
$B%?%P%3$rKW<}$5$l(B
$B$F(B
$B!V$A$'!*%P!<%m! $B$C$F(B
$BF|K\8lOC$;$k$8$c$s!*(B
$B%"%O%O(B

12$B7n(B17$BF|!!!VDY$l$k@#A0!)!W(B

$B$=$l$^$G$O(B
$BBh(B2$B$HBh#4?eMKF|$O!V!o(B350$B$,H>3[$N!o(B175$B!W$@$C$?(B
$B$N$K(B
10(I%(B11$B7n$O!VFCJL%-%c%s%Z!<%s!W$G!o(B200
$B$C$F(B
$BCM>e$2%-%c%s%Z!<%s$r$d$C$F$?6a=j$N%l%s%?%k%S%G%*20(B
$B$O(B
12$B7n$K$J$C$F$bBh(B2$B$HBh#4?eMKF|(B
$B$O(B
$B!VFCJL%-%c%s%Z!<%s!W$G!o(B200
$B$C$F(B
$BCM>e$2$7$?%^%s%^$8$c$s!*(B
$B$7$+$b(B
$B%]%$%s%H$bIU$+$J$/$7$F!*(B
$B$J$a$H$s$N$+$"(B!!!

12$B7n(B16$BF|!!!V%T%C%/%s%T%C%/%s!W(B

$BM $B$G(B
$BKM$NA0$KN)$C$F$?%*%C%5%s(B
$B$O(B
$B%+%P%s$r$V$i2<$2$?KM$N $B0U<1$7$F$+(B
$B%1%D$N6ZFy$r%T%C%/%s%T%C%/%s$5$;$F$?(B
$B%[%b$N%5%$%s!)(B

12$B7n(B15$BF|!!!VK:$lJ*!W(B

TV$B%7%g%C%T%s%0(B
$B$G(B
$B!VI($^$G29$+$$%K%C%H$N%Q%s%D!W(B
$B$H$$$&$N$r$d$C$F$?(B
$B$,(B
$B$=$3$K=P$FMh$?%*%P!<%A%c%s(B
$B$O(B
$B!V$b$& $B$C$F(B
$B%3%i! $B%9%+!<%H$a$/$C$F%Q%s%D8+$;$k$J$"!*(B
$B%"%O%O(B

12$B7n(B14$BF|!!!VK:$lJ*!W(B

$B6a=j$NF;$rJb$$$F$?(B
$B$i(B
$B2#F;$+$iMh$?%*%P%5%s(B
$B$O(B
$B=P2q$$F,$KM'C#$K=P$/$o$7(B
$B$F(B
$BC}$m$&$H$7$?ESC<(B
$B!V(B$B$"$C!*F~;uK:$l$?!*%"%O%O%O%O%O(B$B!W(B
$B$C$F(B
$B%o%C%O%C%O!

12$B7n(B13$BF|!!!V%5%s%?$JBp5^JX!W(B

$B:rF|$NLkCY$/%?%P%3$rGc$$$K9T$C$?(B
$B$,(B
$B:#F|D+Aa$/%I%"$r3+$1$?(B
$B$i(B
$B%I%"%N%V(B
$B$K(B
$BBp5^JX$,$V$i2<$,$C$F$?(B
$B$C$F;v$O(B
$BLkCf$KMh$?$N!)(B
$B%5%s%?$5$s$_$?$$$JBp5^JX20$5$s$@$J$"(B
$B%"%O%O(B

12$B7n(B12$BF|!!!V$4D9

$B;RJu$K7C$^$l(B
$B$F(B
$B!V0lI1FsB@O:!W(B
$B$J$s$F8@$&(B
$B$,(B
$B$=$N(B3$B7;Do$,D9@8$-$7$?(B
$B$i(B
$B!V0l%P%PFs%8%8!W(B
$B$C$F(B
$B8@$&$s$@$m$&$+!)(B
$B%"%O%O(B

12$B7n(B11$BF|!!!V?76d9T!W(B

$B$^$?(B
$B6d9T$,9gJ;$9$k$=$&$@(B
$B$,(B
$B$=$NL>A0(B
$B$,(B
$B!V;0I)El5~(BUFJ$B6d9T!W(B
$B$C$F(B
$B%o%C%O%C%O! $BEl5~;0I)$r$R$C$/$jJV$7$F(B
UFJ$B$K$/$CIU$1$?$@$1$8$c$s!*(B
$B%R%M%j$,$J$$$>$*!*(B

12$B7n(B10$BF|!!!V%*%d%8$N:B!W(B

$BD+$N%i%8%*$G$d$C$F$?!V%5%i%j!<%^%s@nLx!W(B
$B%*%d%8$N:B(B
$B@N$O>2$N4V(B
$B:#(B
$BJX:B(B
$B%o%C%O%C%O!

12$B7n(B9$BF|!!!V$3$3$O!W(B

$B:#F|$O(B
$B8E$$;E;vCg4V(B4$B?M(B
$B$G(B
$B%@%Y%C%FMh$?(B
$B3Z$7$+$C$?(B
$B$C$F(B
$B>.3X@8$N:nJ8$+$"!*(B

12$B7n(B8$BF|!!!V8e$m!W(B

$B:.$s$G$kEE $B$G(B
$B2?8N$@$+;~!9(B
$B8e$m$+$iI($r%,%/%C$H2!$5$l$?(B
$B$,(B
$B8e$m$N?M$N=E$$2YJ*$,Ev$C$F$k$s$@$m$&(B
$B$H(B
$B;W$C$F$?(B
$B$i(B
$B%&%s%3:B$j$7$?%*%M%(!<%A%c%s$,?2$F$F(B
$B$=$NF,$,KM$NI(N"$rD>7b$7$F$?(B
$B%3%i! $B$b$&$A$g$C$H>e$N1|$K$*4j$$$7$^$9$M(B
$B%"%O%O(B

12$B7n(B7$BF|!!!VGz?g!W(B

$B:#F|$b(B
$B?e8M2+Lg:FJ|Aw$r8+;O$a$?(B
$BESC<(B
$BGz?g$7(B
$BL\$,3P$a$?$iHVAH$N:G8e(B
$B$G(B
$B2+LgMM$,!V%o%C%O%C%O!W(B
$B$H(B
$B>P$C$F$?(B
$B%8%8%$$K>P$o$l$F$I!<$9$k!*(B

12$B7n(B6$BF|!!!VJu$/$8!W(B

$BDA$7$/Ju$/$8$rGc$C$?(B
$B$,(B
$BGc$&;~$K(B
$B!VEv$k$N%P%i$G(B10$BKg$A$g$&$@$$!*!W(B
$B$H8@$C$?(B
$B$i(B
$B%*%P%A%c%s(B
$B$,(B
$B%K%d%C$H>P$C$F(B
$B!V$O$$!*I,$:Ev$k$N%P%i$G(B10$BKg$M!*!W(B
$B$C$F(B
$BEv$i$J$+$C$?$iF,Df$l$h$J$"(B
$B%"%O%O(B

12$B7n(B5$BF|!!!VCf$G!W(B

Mac$B$NCf$K;E9~$s$G$"$k29EY7W(B
$B$O(B
$B2F$N@9$j$K(B35$B!nA08e(B
$B$G(B
$B=)??$C@9$j$K$O(B25$B!nA08e(B
$B$@$C$?$,(B
$B%9%C%2%(!<4($+$C$?:#F|(B
$B$O(B
18$B!n(B
$B$C$F(B
$B$=$NFbCf$G@c$,9_$i$J$$$+$"!)(B
$B%"%O%O(B

12$B7n(B4$BF|!!!VO7$1!W(B

$B1JO;Je$N%i%8%*HVAH(B
$B$G(B
$B:P$N$;$$$GB-$r$/$8$$$?1JO;Je(B
$B$r(B
$B=w@-%"%J%&%s%5!<(B
$B$C$F$P(B
$B!V$($$(B $B$m$/(B$B$U$1(B$B!W(B
$B$C$F(B
$B%o%C%O%C%O! $B1v(B30$B%-%m!*(B

12$B7n(B3$BF|!!!VF1@3$7$^$;$s$+!)!W(B

$B!V(B$BF1@3$7$^$;$s$+!)!W(B
$B$H$$$&%9%Q%`%a!<%k$,Mh$?(B
$B%"%O%O(B
$B$=$s$J;v$$$-$J$j8@$o$l$F$b$J$"!&!&!&(B
$B$($C$H(B
$B9M$($H$-$^$9$s$G!&!&!&(B
$B9M$($k$J$"!*(B

12$B7n(B2$BF|!!!VN)$A0LCV$H8~$-!W(B

$B1XA0$N(BATM$B$X9T$C$?(B
$B$i(B
$BAk8}$G%*%P%"%A%c%s$,BT$C$F$$$?(B
$B$N$G(B
$B8e$m$KJB$s$@(B
$B$i(B
$B$9$02#$N%(%l%Y!<%?!<$,3+$$$?(B
$BESC<(B
$B%*%P%"%A%c%s$,>h$C$F$C$?(B
$B%"%O%O(B
$B$"$N!

12$B7n(B1$BF|!!!V%P%+%d%m!

$B:rF|(B
$B?7=I$N2NIq4lD.$N0lJb $B$G(B
$BC/$,8+$?$C$F!V$=$N6Z!W$N%*%K!<%A%c%s(B
$B$,(B
$B@V?.9f$J$N$KF;$r2#CG$7$F $B!V8+$($M$(!<$N$+%P%+%d%m! $B$H(B
$BE\LD$C$F$?(B
$B!V8+$($M$(!<$N$+%P%+%d%m! $B$O(B
$B%*%a%(!<$@$h!*(B

$B!|(B


1999$B!!(B7$B!!(B8$B!!(B9$B!!(B10$B!!(B11$B!!(B12$B!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!(B
2000$B!!(B1$B!!(B2$B!!(B3$B!!(B4$B!!(B5$B!!(B6$B!!(B7$B!!(B8$B!!(B9$B!!(B10$B!!(B11$B!!(B12
2001$B!!(B1$B!!(B2$B!!(B3$B!!(B4$B!!(B5$B!!(B6$B!!(B7$B!!(B8$B!!(B9$B!!(B10$B!!(B11$B!!(B12
2002$B!!(B1$B!!(B2$B!!(B3$B!!(B4$B!!(B5$B!!(B6$B!!(B7$B!!(B8$B!!(B9$B!!(B10$B!!(B11$B!!(B12
$B!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!(B2003$B!!(B1$B!!(B2$B!!(B3$B!!(B4$B!!(B5$B!!(B6$B!!(B7$B!!(B8$B!!(B9$B!!(B10$B!!(B11$B!!(B12$B!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!(B
$B!!(B2004$B!!(B1$B!!(B2$B!!(B3$B!!(B4$B!!(B5$B!!(B6$B!!(B7$B!!(B8$B!!(B9$B!!(B10$B!!(B11$B!!(B12$B!!(B
2005$B!!(B1$B!!(B2$B!!(B3$B!!(B4$B!!(B5$B!!(B6$B!!(B7$B!!(B8$B!!(B9$B!!(B10$B!!(B11$B!!(B12
2006$B!!(B1$B!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!(B



@
$B%(%L(Bekoya@din.or.jp
$B%9%Q%`BP:v$N0Y!"F,$N(Bn$B$r%(%L$K$7$F$"$j$^$9!#(B
$B$*.J8;z$N(Bn$B$KBe$($F2<$5$$!#(B